I don't normally rant that often. Well, not here anyway. I find more satisfaction speaking my thoughts out and including swear words whenever I rant. But today I've decided to make an exception.
I basically get annoyed at purists and their holier-than-thou attitude when talking about music. It seems that unless a certain genre is done a certain way, then anything else besides that is a simply unacceptable and lame. I seem to come across it more often than not whenever I read comments on music websites *sigh* Why can't we agree to disagree that there is more than one specific genre of music out there and it CAN be mixed or varied or changed depending on the taste of the artist or the audience?
Example in case would be Big Bang and their concept of hip-hop/pop/techno/whatever you wish to categorize them and how it differs from that of the American/English music scene.
It annoys me to a certain extent when people randomly point out that 50 cent is thug and Big Bang is not. Cos yes, they are not 50 cent/Lil Wayne/insert name of any American rapper here. They didn't get shot a gazillion times in their body. They didn't live on the streets. There was no history of discrimination. They don't carry guns and they are not scared that they might get shot by a passing car (I'm aware that I'm generalizing here) So how do you expect them to behave and act the way their American counterparts act?
If purists can't stand the music, don't listen to it. Change the channel. There are a gazillion artists out there. If you can compare them and critic them saying that isn't the way their supposed to act/sing, then you can go find and artist who fits your taste and your needs. Support them and buy their album. Show them that you like their music and that there is a market for them (But I swear, once some of these artists get famous, these purists would turn their backs on the artist they like and label them as sell outs just cos they're now being liked by the masses...*sigh* they can never be pleased) I mean, constructive criticism is good if its focused on the artists themselves and their music. Bad lyrics are bad in whatever language it is. Lame beats are lame in whatever genre it is. Say it and end it there. Don't act all high and mighty saying that the way they act/sing/compose/write is wrong and not "true" hip hop.
My take on it is that it isn't really fair to compare them (or any other korean or foriegn rappers/hip hop acts) with English/American rappers. The similarities are there but the music industry, the history, the society, the language, the culture, their influences and their experiences are vastly different from the English/American side. You can’t expect them to be gangsters/thugs/street/whatever exactly the way the English/Americans are when the concept itself doesn’t even have its roots in Korean culture or society. I'm sure 50 cent would rather shoot himself than bow to Kanye West and call him "Sunbaenim" (an honourific given by younger Koreans to those who are senior then them in the same business) or vice versa whilst Big Bang would probably be the first to bow and do that whenever they meet any senior artist regardless of who it was in the Korean music industry. Hip hop in Korean is basically a borrowed/transplanted concept and can be changed, varied and butchered however much they want it to be to suit theirs/audience/society’s taste.
Phew. That was a long one. Constructive comments/opinions would be appreciated.